Wednesday 4 December 2013

"Cost of Transport" - a new way of calculating the energy used for movement



Regulars to the Thursday class (1-2.30 pm at BNHC) know that Laurie and I have been playing around with the idea that the jellyfish is the purest fascial movement based organism that we can think of.

Of course the jelly like substance of the jellyfish and our collagen-based fascia is not identical but they share many properties, which leads us to postulate that it affects movement in a similar way.

Jellyfish are an ancient life form on the evolutionary ladder, which raises several questions as to when our fascia formed in the timescale of human evolution.

This blog update is about another interesting aspect of the jellyfish and it’s movement.

We have all seen the graceful way a jellyfish propels itself through the water, it is hypnotic, so much so that in Japan they observe tanks of jellyfish as a way to reduce stress.

In a recent article in the Sunday Times (20th October 2013) researchers in the U.S. have named the Moon Jellyfish (the most common type) ‘the most efficient swimmers on the planet’.

Brad J Gemmell of the Marine Biological Lab in Massachusetts has analysed the movement of the Moon jellyfish.

Brad, like Laurie and I has had trouble describing this movement in conventional language, there just are not the words available to us. So like us (we invented the word Myolastic), he has invented some new terms to describe the way the Jellyfish moves.

He invented a new way of describing and calculating the energy used in Jellyfish (fascial!!) movement calling it the “the cost of transport”
i.e. how much energy used to move.

He observed a 2 phase swimming motion:

Phase 1- jellyfish contracts it’s open bell and pulses water behind it, propelling itself forward.
Phase 2 – Jellyfish returns to its original bell shape as the bell refills with water.
Traditionally Phase 1 is the active phase, the contractile stage and Phase 2 is the passive or recovery stage.

However it has been shown that the second phase is also creating a push of it’s own, accounting for 30% of the distance travelled without actually doing any work! This is because the elastic tissue (their description not mine) of the bell, acts like an elastic band, reforming the bell and it is this action that produces a water action under the jellyfish called a vortex, which pushes it forward. This recovery stage and the kick it produces is, they believe, purely mechanical and VERY energy efficient.
The question is can our fascia be as efficient?

Our fascia is made up of two substances, collagen and elastin. We know that the location and use determine the exact quantities of the two substances. We also know that use or load placed upon the fascia can lead to changes in the ratio of collagen and elastin in a tissue at a specific site.

The fascial tissue or connective tissue in our body has an elastic quality. We know it stores energy and releases it, with huge efficiency such as can be seen when a kangaroo jumps.

(All of the above can be read about in previous blogs on the MMP site and www.Traceymellorpilates.co.uk blog site.)

The speed/strength of the return to original size and shape is what determines the elastic capability of a tissue or substance. Stainless steel has a high elastic capability for instance. The elastic of a jellyfish also has a highly elastic capability, giving it a low “cost of transport”.

It is possible to feel the restoration of shape in our tissue in the quiet stillness of non-movement, we have been exploring how this feels in our classes and workshops.

So what is our “cost of transport”? Can we improve it with training or is it there already just waiting for us to recognise it’s existence?


Tracey Mellor

© December 2013